The Age-Old Martini Debate: Shaken or Stirred? Frozen?
Can you really "bruise" the gin for a martini by shaking it? Some purists claim that shaking a martini disrupts its delicate balance by over-aerating or diluting the gin too quickly. But here at Conniption, we say it’s all about personal preference. After all, who can argue with how satisfying an ice-cold, shaken martini is after a long day?
When to Shake or Stir?
- Classic Martinis with delicate vermouth? Stirring preserves the silky texture and prevents unnecessary dilution.
- Martinez or Vesper? Traditionally stirred to maintain their rich, sweet complexity.
- Dirty Martinis? Shaking blends the olive brine perfectly into the gin, creating that frosty, savory sip.
At Conniption, our Navy Strength Gin and American Dry Gin are designed to stand up to either method. Whether you love the crispness of a shaken martini or the smoothness of a stirred one, you can’t go wrong with either.
“There is no definitive answer—just preference” (source).
Martini Inspiration from Conniption Gin
At Corpse Reviver Cocktail Bar & Lounge, Melissa Katrincic’s Dirty Martini, crafted with Navy Strength Gin, is a fan favorite and the most popular martini on the menu. Once you take a sip, you'll forget that you made dirty martinis any other way - and certainly not with vodka.
For a classic experience, try the House Dry Martini, inspired by the legendary Duke’s Bar in London, where martinis are pre-batched and served straight from the freezer for an icy, smooth sip without shaking or stirring. It’s the perfect option for those looking to recreate that frozen martini magic at home.
For something a bit more adventurous, explore the Martinez—the forebear of the modern martini. Our version with Barrel-Aged Gin brings a touch of nostalgia and complexity.
Or, make a bold statement with the color-shifting Purple Rain, featuring Conniption Kinship Gin and floral notes.
Finally, Lee Katrincic’s favorite is the Turf Club, a sophisticated cocktail perfect for those seeking something classic yet unique. Explore all these and more in our Cocktail Collection.
